Wrapping up 7.4 (finally)
skeggsb at gmail.com
Fri Jun 13 06:49:26 PDT 2008
On Fri, 2008-06-13 at 09:14 -0400, Gene Heskett wrote:
> On Friday 13 June 2008, Daniel Stone wrote:
> >On Thu, Jun 12, 2008 at 11:12:57PM -0300, pcpa at mandriva.com.br wrote:
> >> BTW I think nouveau, open source, 3d enabled nvidia cards support, should
> >> be available in 7.4, due to large amount of users with these cards...
> >The nouveau driver will be included in a release when the nouveau
> >developers ask for it to be included, rather than explicitly ask for it
> >to not be included.
> The present difficulty in obtaining this driver is what sent me to town 6 months
> ago for a better ATI card, which it turned out is not supported either, so I
> reverted to a several year old ati card, which is working reasonably well if
> somewhat slower than the nvidia cards ran with the binaries, till the kernel
> people decided that nvidia will give us the stuff to write a driver, or no more
> I can see the kernel peoples viewpoint, having personally observed too many
> instances of odd, unstable behavior while running the binaries. Not to mention
> I can't let one of them anywhere near my milling machine due to the nvidia
> blobs knocking out the IRQ's for many milliseconds when it has work to do.
> Because its stepper driven, the pulses must be at a very steady rate when the
> speed rise, and I went from 9 inchs a minute to nearly 35 just by reverting to
> the vesa driver for an nvidia card.
> I would like to try this new driver, particularly on that machine and would give
> them feedback on how its working, but when its as hard to download and build it
> as it is now, that is so not going to happen.
> Tell these folks that hiding their code under a basket is not going to get it
> tested in the real world. Put it out there and let us play with it, and it
> will be ready for prime time a lot faster. The current situation is not, IMO,
> justifiable. Its either dead or its alive, napping in a locked closet doesn't
Let me restate this again: We can *NOT* support our kernel interfaces as
the currently are into the future, as such can't do a "release". As it
is I have a couple of changes pending which we'll need to support 3D on
G8x/G9x chipsets, not to mention memory management.
The code isn't hidden, nor is it any harder to build than building every
other DRM/DDX module in existance (it's *exactly* the same).. If the
lack of binary packages is a problem for you, bug your distro
maintainers and let them deal with regularly changing interfaces. We
have a lot of issues/features to handle without worrying about backwards
compatibility just yet.
More information about the xorg