[Linaro-mm-sig] [PATCH v3 1/2] habanalabs: define uAPI to export FD for DMA-BUF

[Jason Gunthorpe]

On Wed, Jun 23, 2021 at 10:57:35AM +0200, Christian König wrote:

> > > No it isn't. It makes devices depend on allocating struct pages for their
> > > BARs which is not necessary nor desired.
> > Which dramatically reduces the cost of establishing DMA mappings, a
> > loop of dma_map_resource() is very expensive.
> 
> Yeah, but that is perfectly ok. Our BAR allocations are either in chunks of
> at least 2MiB or only a single 4KiB page.

And very small apparently
 
> > > Allocating a struct pages has their use case, for example for exposing VRAM
> > > as memory for HMM. But that is something very specific and should not limit
> > > PCIe P2P DMA in general.
> > Sure, but that is an ideal we are far from obtaining, and nobody wants
> > to work on it prefering to do hacky hacky like this.
> > 
> > If you believe in this then remove the scatter list from dmabuf, add a
> > new set of dma_map* APIs to work on physical addresses and all the
> > other stuff needed.
> 
> Yeah, that's what I totally agree on. And I actually hoped that the new P2P
> work for PCIe would go into that direction, but that didn't materialized.

It is a lot of work and the only gain is to save a bit of memory for
struct pages. Not a very big pay off.
 
> But allocating struct pages for PCIe BARs which are essentially registers
> and not memory is much more hacky than the dma_resource_map() approach.

It doesn't really matter. The pages are in a special zone and are only
being used as handles for the BAR memory.

> By using PCIe P2P we want to avoid the round trip to the CPU when one device
> has filled the ring buffer and another device must be woken up to process
> it.

Sure, we all have these scenarios, what is inside the memory doesn't
realy matter. The mechanism is generic and the struct pages don't care
much if they point at something memory-like or at something
register-like.

They are already in big trouble because you can't portably use CPU
instructions to access them anyhow.

Jason