[Clipart] And the Winner is... + Need Independent Verification

Fri Sep 3 20:18:18 PDT 2004

Could someone please verify my counting. I'm attaching my file which
compares the 13 votes received on the Clip Art mailing list. Remember,
we decided to use the Instant Runoff system as described here:

http://www.gpde.org/Issues/Election_Reform/Instant_runoff_voting.htm

The winner by my vote is:

Andreas Nilssons
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg
which is the same as ocallogo.svg

The one complaint and something which needs to be reworked, which I can
take on is the text next to the graphic.

Please, one other person check my work and then we will commit to this
logo for the next 6 months at least. I will pretty it up and put on the
website, etc.

Jon

-- 
Jon Phillips

KOREA.PH.010.3140.7483
USA.PH.858.361.2811
jon at rejon.org
http://www.rejon.org

Inkscape (http://inkscape.org)
Open Clip Art Library (www.openclipart.org)
CVS Book (http://cvsbook.ucsd.edu/)
Scale Journal (http://scale.ucsd.edu/)
-------------- next part --------------
Vote on Logos
=============

ROUND 1
=======

1. Andreas Nilssons
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg
1. http://openclipart.org/clipart/OCALLogos/ocallogo.svg
>1.
>http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_02_gallery_01.png

1.  http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_06.svg
1. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_09.svg
   (or one of the variations)
1.
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_02_gallery_01.svg
1. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_07.svg
- Author: Samir Bharadwaj / Title: OCAL logo 01
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_08.svg
1.  http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_10.svg
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/ocal_logo_0.5_01.svg
1) Andreas' logo looks nice.
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg

1. Andreas Nilssons
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg
which is same as ocallogo X 3 votes

2. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_02_gallery_01.svg X 2

3. scissors style X 2 (6 and 7 and 11)

ROUND 2
=======

1. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_09.svg
   (or one of the variations)
2.
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg
   (changing slightly the text)

1. - Author: Samir Bharadwaj / Title: OCAL logo 01
2. - Author: Andreas Nilsson / Title: Open Clip Art Library logo

1. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_08.svg
had to go to 3rd cuz threw out his 2nd in 1st round
3. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg

1. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_10.svg
2. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_01_gallery_01.svg

http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/ocal_logo_0.5_01.svg
(had to throw out because not a second vote)

COMBINED VOTE
=============

1. Andreas Nilssons
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg
which is same as ocallogo X 7 votes

2.
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_02_gallery_01.svg
X 2

3. scissors style X 2 (6 and 7 and 11)

WINNER
======

1. Andreas Nilssons
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg
which is same as ocallogo X 7 votes

####

VOTERS from MAILING LIST
========================

VOTE 1
======

1. Andreas Nilssons
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg

2. Henrich Fichnas
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/logotype_ocal_01.png

3. Bonos http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/ocal_logo_0.5_01.svg

VOTE 2
======

1. http://openclipart.org/clipart/OCALLogos/ocallogo.svg
2. http://openclipart.org/clipart/OCALLogos/logotype_ocal_01.svg
3.
http://openclipart.org/clipart/OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_02_gallery_01.svg

VOTE 3
======

>1.
>http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_02_gallery_01.png
>>2.  http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/ocal_logo_02_01.png
>>3.
>>http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/logo_proposal_for_ocal_by_nicu_03_01.png

VOTE 4
======

1.  http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_06.svg

essentailly I'm voting that the Scissors should become our identifying
logo, it is a near universal symbol and immediately recongisable, so much
so that I can represent it in ASCII as shown.

-----8<-----

----->8----

2.  http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_07.svg

This logo is so similiar to the previous one it hardly makes sense to vote
for it seperately but I'm doing so anyway.

-----8<-----

3.
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_01_gallery_01.png

Andy Fitzsimons artwork is excellent and although I dont think it is ideal
as the Scissors I do think that it is a beautiful piece of artwork that we
should seriously try to make use of in some way, if not as a logo perhaps
as banner adds or perhaps as a splash screen/about dialog for one of the
releases.

VOTE 5
======

1. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_09.svg
   (or one of the variations)

2. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg
   (changing slightly the text)

3.
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_02_gallery_01.svg

VOTE 6
======

1. 
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_02_gallery_01.svg
2. 
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_01_gallery_01.svg
3. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_08.svg

VOTE 7
======

1. Andrew Fitzsimon's path logo:
   http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_01_gallery_01.svg
   (Not the whole thing as one logo, but the colored logo for
   situations where color is wanted, with the black-and-white versions
   to be used in situations where color is not wanted.)

2. Henrich Fichna's abstract logo, four overlapping circles:
   http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/logotype_ocal_01.svg
   (Again, not the whole thing as one, but the blue one where color
   is wanted and black otherwise -- and for small sizes just the
   graphic element without the text.)

3. Bono's diamond-shaped logo:
   http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/ocal_logo_0.5_01.svg
   (Again, without the text at small sizes.)

VOTE 8
======

1. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_07.svg
2. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_06.svg
3.
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg
(http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/ocallogo.svg)

VOTE 9
======

- Author: Samir Bharadwaj / Title: OCAL logo 01
- Author: Andreas Nilsson / Title: Open Clip Art Library logo
- Author: Henrich Fichna / Title: logotype_OCAL

VOTE 10
=======

http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_08.svg
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_10.svg
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg

with honorable mention to:

http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/logo_proposal_for_ocal_by_nicu_03_01.svg

VOTE 11
=======

1.  http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_10.svg

2. 
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clipart_library_proposal_01_gallery_01.svg

3. http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_06.svg

VOTE 12: Thrown out because it is only 1 vote and not for top 3
=======

http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/ocal_logo_0.5_01.svg
without the little problems in the text (i don't know, maybe is it my viewer)
(had to throw out!!! because only one vote)

VOTE 13
=======

1) Andreas' logo looks nice.
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_library_logo_01.svg

2) I like the idea of scissors.
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_logo_10.svg

3) Niel's box looks interesting, but I am not sure how it relates to the
project.
http://openclipart.org/clipart//OCALLogos/open_clip_art_librarylogo_01.svg