[Libreoffice-qa] DOCX Test 5 Results

[Joel Madero]

This is all fantastic Jay.

A couple questions:

(1) Are you searching for duplicates before reporting? Some of these
(I'd hope many?) have already been reported.

(2) For sample test documents - if you can create the most simple test
case it makes life much much happier for our developers. If you provide
a 20 page sample document and say "page 15 has this problem" they have
to dig through a ton of xml crap to actually figure out where the
problem is.


All in all, fantastic work :)


Best,
Joel


On 05/09/2014 07:20 PM, Jay Philips wrote:
> Hi All,
>
> I just wanted to share with you all the results of my latest extended
> .docx test. I have been able to refine my workflow to better test,
> document and report the compatibility issues, and was able to put in
> 13 bug reports yesterday. Also i noticed there is a weekly bug summary
> page and i'm at 1st place in bug reporting. :)
>
> file url:
> http://download.microsoft.com/documents/uk/partner/publicsector/DraftMicrosoftResponsetoGovernment.docx
> file contents: response letter, text & table & lists, 19 pages, 48Kb
>
> Results
> --------
>  docx - page 14: table appears outside of right margin because cell
> padding and column widths [regression since 4.1] [reported 78227]
>       - page 15 & 17: some numeric and bullet lists didnt retain
> character color [previously reported 77797]
>       - page 17: space between bullet list bullet and text is
> incorrect [reported 78352]
>  doc  - perfect except for the bullet list between spacing
>  ---
>  export doc - page 14: table border color not retained [3.6 - 4.2,
> including 4.2.5, its fine in 4.3] [reported 78347]
>             - numeric list characters on page 15 are correct, but
> bullet list bullets on page 17 are black
>  export doc in word 2010 - page 15: numeric list bullet '2' shows in
> black
>                          - page 17: bullet list bullets are grey like
> the original docx
>  export docx - page 15 & 17: numeric and bullet list characters are in
> black
>  export docx in word 2010 - page 17: bullet list bullets are grey like
> the original docx
>  export odt 1.1 - page 17: bullet list bullets in black and no
> indentation between it and following text [3.6 - 4.3] [reported 78351]
>  export odt 1.2 & odt 1.2 ext - same as original
>  export odt 1.1 & 1.2 in word 2010 - page 14: table left position
> slightly outside of left margin
>                                    - links on page 14, 15 & 17 appear
> in black without an underline instead of blue with underline[3.6 -
> 4.3] [reported 78514]
>                                    - page 15: numeric list indentation
> is incorrect
>  export rtf - paragraph and line spacing not opened correctly [4.0 to
> 4.2dev space increases, 4.3 spacing shrinks, 3.6 it was perfect]
>             - font colors not opened correctly (fileopen problem only
> in 4.2) [previously reported 78313]
>             - page 17: bullet list character not retained [reported
> 78492]
>             - links with black instead of blue underline (fileopen
> problem) [3.6 - 4.3] [reported 78357]
>             - table cell padding not retained [reported 78491]
>             - page 15: number list indentation [reported 78495]
>  export rtf in word 2010 - looked the same as LibO, except for the rtf
> filesave errors [table padding, number list indent, bullet character]
>                          - found double spacing issue [reported 78497]
>  ---
>  kingsoft doc - font styles (bold, size, spacing) not retained
> [previously reported 78143]
>  kingsoft docx - page 15: numeric list numbers in incorrect color
> [previously reported 77797]
>  kingsoft rtf - not openable in LibO 3.6 and 4.0 [previously reported
> 77861]
>               - page 1: beginning of document starts of with multiple
> ';' characters [reported 78502]
>               - page 14: links shown as Times New Roman 11pt
> superscript when they should be Calibri 11pt [reported 78504]
>               - page 15: numeric list number character shown as
> '10!broken!!' rather than '1.', which causes indent and font issues
> (kingsoft partial problem) [reported 78506]
>  ---
>  word 2013 doc - perfect
>  word 2013 docx strict - had problem with line spacing, table was
> crashed [reported 78508], extra space between bullet list bullet
> character and text
>  word 2013 rtf - font color of numeric and bullet list characters are
> black
>  word 2013 odt - links show up in dark blue [reported 78509], bullet
> list bullets in wrong location [reported 78510]
>  word 2011 odt - links show up in dark blue and numeric & bullet lists
> are indented more (ms office problem)
> --------
>
> Rating: C- for good display of original file, small problems with
> tables in .docx files, and significant problems with importing and
> exporting of rtf
>
> Hope everyone has a good weekend.
>