[pulseaudio-discuss] Equalizer setting is forgotten until PA is restarted and sound stutters
szakacs.zsolt at zoho.com
Wed Jul 9 06:54:43 PDT 2014
On 2014-07-08 12:40, Jason Newton wrote:
> On Mon, Jul 7, 2014 at 8:47 AM, Zsolt Szakácswrote:
> I'm using the equalizer sink for PulseAudio 4.0 under SolydK so
> that my subwoofer emits sound only about 80 Hz and below in my 5.1
> sound system. (I wanted to try another solution to do this, as I
> wrote in my post on Stackexchange here
> but it wasn't successful.) Also, I'm using gstreamer.
> One problem is that every time I reboot, the settings in qpaeq
> don't seem to take effect. Even if I open qpaeq and start moving
> the scales, the change is not reflected in the sound at all.
> However, if I enter /pulseaudio -k/ and then /pulseaudio -D/ in
> the terminal, I can hear that equalization is applied.
> Re the equalizer, this sounds very odd, perhaps somehow one of the
> modules is not loaded when your desktop environment starts pulse?
> Could you try using pacmd list-modules and look for
> module-dbus-protocol and module-equalizer-sink on such conditions?
> Are you sure applications are being routed through the equalizer? A
> good way to check is pavucontrol.
> Another problem is that when the equalized sink is the default
> sink, sound stutters when watching a video on YouTube with Firefox
> and Flash or playing an mp3 with VLC. However, there is stuttering
> only at the beginning or the end of playing (when I select stop)
> or jumping to a particular position while playing a video in
> SMplayer, Mplayer, VLC, or listening to music in Clementine.
> These are buffering issues manifesting with flash and others with
> events causing a rewind (start/stop/seek) when multiple sources are
> active - my advice for now is to not use flash and the equalizer
> together and instead have flash content go directly to the device
> sink. The rewind issues on multiple sources is another long standing
> issue to fix but if you do not have multiple sources active, it will
> not manifest. For what its worth, they are problems I want to look
> into to characterize better and fix but I am months out from having
> the luxury of time to do it.
> pulseaudio-discuss mailing list
> pulseaudio-discuss at lists.freedesktop.org
I've checked the loaded modules and both before and after restarting PA
both module-dbus-protocol and module-equalizer-sink are loaded. However,
I also noticed that a few modules are not loaded again after restarting
PA, namely /module-device-manager//, module-x11-publish,
//module-x11-cork-request/, and /module-x11-xsmp/.
I've also checked pavucontrol (thanks for mentioning it), and it looks
like the equalized sink doesn't get any signal until I switch the output
in the playback tab (but then it reverts back to the unequalized 5.1
sink after playing another audio or video file) or I restart PA from
Also, as for the issue with Flash, interestingly, if I switch to the
equalized sink inside pavucontrol, there is no stuttering apart from for
a short time after I switch, but, again, this is a temporary solution.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the pulseaudio-discuss