On Fri, 2019-11-08 at 20:30 -0600, Anthony Joseph Messina wrote:
> Thank you for responding Ryan. AFAIK, I don't have both systemd-
> networkd and
> NetworkManager "running" or enabled. In fact, I have had
> NetworkManager
> disabled on these systems for some time (back through F27, I
> believe). Post
> upgrade (or fresh install) I ensure that NetworkManager is not re-
> enabled, and
> that systemd-networkd is enabled.
> Unforuntately, trying to remove
> NetworkManager completely seems like a heavy hammer based on the `dnf
> remove`
> output below.
Seems dnf wants to also unstall packages that were installed due to
NetworkManager. For exapmle, "libndp" obvoiusly has no dependency on
NetworkManager (but the other way around). You probable should use the
right argument to dnf to not remove unrelated packages.
>
> Also, these identical systemd-networkd configurations do work on F30,
> just not
> on systems upgraded to F31.
>
> The only recent change I notice in F31, is that NetworkManager is
> initialized
> during early boot even when the service is disabled and masked.
NM indeed may now run in early boot. That has no relation to whether
you enable the systemd service ("enabling" a service in systemd anyway
only means to hook it up accroding to the [Install] section, and that
does not cover what runs in initrd).
I would suspect that NetworkManager sets the interface to disable ipv6
address generation (e.g. `ip -d link` would report "addrgenmode none").
It probably shouldn't do so, if there is not configuration for the
device. This is probably a bug.
Another question is what causes NM to run in initrd in the first place.
Usually that would be caused by setting "rd.neednet=1" on the kernel
command line. But dracut may also artificially add such a command line,
according to its configuration. You probably don't want to setup
networking in initrd in the first place. That is, check your dracut
configuration...
best,
Thomas
>
> This is the early boot NetworkManager output:
> <info> [1573262139.2398] NetworkManager (version 1.20.4-1.fc31) is
> starting... (for the first time)
> <info> [1573262139.2399] Read config:
> /etc/NetworkManager/NetworkManager.conf
> <info> [1573262139.2416] auth[0x55b3f3c8b4a0]: create auth-manager:
> D-Bus
> connection not available. Polkit is disabled and all requests are
> authenticated.
> <info> [1573262139.2426] manager[0x55b3f3c94060]: monitoring kernel
> firmware
> directory '/lib/firmware'.
> <info> [1573262139.2427] hostname: hostname: hostnamed not used as
> proxy
> creation failed with: Could not connect: No such file or directory
> <info> [1573262139.2428] hostname: hostname changed from (none) to
> "linux-
> ws1.messinet.com"
> <info> [1573262139.2430] dns-mgr[0x55b3f3c8f210]: init:
> dns=default,systemd-
> resolved rc-manager=symlink
> <info> [1573262139.2447] Loaded device plugin: NMTeamFactory
> (/usr/lib64/
> NetworkManager/1.20.4-1.fc31/libnm-device-plugin-team.so)
> <info> [1573262139.2448] manager: rfkill: Wi-Fi enabled by radio
> killswitch;
> enabled by state file
> <info> [1573262139.2448] manager: rfkill: WWAN enabled by radio
> killswitch;
> enabled by state file
> <info> [1573262139.2448] manager: Networking is enabled by state
> file
> <info> [1573262139.2448] dhcp-init: Using DHCP client 'internal'
> <info> [1573262139.2453] settings: Loaded settings plugin: ifcfg-rh
> ("/usr/
> lib64/NetworkManager/1.20.4-1.fc31/libnm-settings-plugin-ifcfg-
> rh.so")
> <info> [1573262139.2454] settings: Loaded settings plugin: keyfile
> (internal)
> <info> [1573262139.2459] device (lo): carrier: link connected
> <info> [1573262139.2460] manager: (lo): new Generic device
> (/org/freedesktop/
> NetworkManager/Devices/1)
> <info> [1573262139.2464] manager: (eno1): new Ethernet device (/org/
> freedesktop/NetworkManager/Devices/2)
> <info> [1573262139.2466] device (eno1): state change: unmanaged ->
> unavailable (reason 'managed', sys-iface-state: 'external')
> <warn> [1573262139.4343] sleep-monitor-sd: failed to acquire D-Bus
> proxy:
> Could not connect: No such file or directory
> <warn> [1573262139.4343] firewall: could not connect to system D-Bus
> (Could
> not connect: No such file or directory)
> <warn> [1573262139.4344] ifcfg-rh: dbus: couldn't initialize system
> bus:
> Could not connect: No such file or directory
>
> ~]# dnf --assumeno remove NetworkManager
> Dependencies resolved.
> =====================================================================
> =====================================================================
> =====================================================================
> =====================================================================
> ======
> Package
>
> Architecture Version
>
> Repository Size
> =====================================================================
> =====================================================================
> =====================================================================
> =====================================================================
> ======
> Removing:
> NetworkManager
>
> x86_64 1:1.20.4-
> 1.fc31
> @fedora 9.6 M
> Removing dependent packages:
> NetworkManager-
> adsl
> x86_64 1:1.20.4-
> 1.fc31
> @fedora 52 k
> NetworkManager-
> bluetooth
> x86_64 1:1.20.4-
> 1.fc31
> @fedora 158 k
> NetworkManager-
> ppp
> x86_64 1:1.20.4-
> 1.fc31
> @fedora 91 k
> initial-setup-
> gui
> x86_64 0.3.76-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 26 k
> plasma-nm-
> l2tp
>
> x86_64 5.16.5-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 378 k
> plasma-nm-
> openconnect
>
> x86_64 5.16.5-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 323 k
> plasma-nm-
> openswan
>
> x86_64 5.16.5-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 162 k
> plasma-nm-
> openvpn
>
> x86_64 5.16.5-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 918 k
> plasma-nm-
> pptp
>
> x86_64 5.16.5-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 301 k
> plasma-nm-
> vpnc
>
> x86_64 5.16.5-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 448 k
> Removing unused dependencies:
> NetworkManager-
> l2tp
> x86_64 1.2.14-
> 1.fc31
>
> @updates 552 k
> NetworkManager-
> libreswan
> x86_64 1.2.12-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 450 k
> NetworkManager-
> openconnect
> x86_64 1.2.6-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 2.2 M
> NetworkManager-
> openvpn
> x86_64 1:1.8.10-
> 1.fc31.1
> @fedora 1.1 M
> NetworkManager-
> pptp
> x86_64 1:1.2.8-
> 1.fc31.2
>
> @fedora 594 k
> NetworkManager-
> team
> x86_64 1:1.20.4-
> 1.fc31
> @fedora 61 k
> NetworkManager-
> vpnc
> x86_64 1:1.2.6-
> 3.fc31
>
> @fedora 620 k
> NetworkManager-
> wifi
> x86_64 1:1.20.4-
> 1.fc31
> @fedora 340 k
> NetworkManager-
> wwan
> x86_64 1:1.20.4-
> 1.fc31
> @fedora 189 k
> anaconda-
> core
>
> x86_64 31.22.6-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 10 M
> anaconda-
> gui
>
> x86_64 31.22.6-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 2.3 M
> anaconda-
> tui
>
> x86_64 31.22.6-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 379 k
> anaconda-user-
> help
> noarch 26.1-
> 10.fc31
>
> @fedora 574 k
> anaconda-
> widgets
>
> x86_64 31.22.6-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 101 k
> bcache-
> tools
>
> x86_64 1.0.8-
> 16.fc31
>
> @fedora 106 k
> blivet-
> data
>
> noarch 1:3.1.5-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 369 k
> blivet-gui-
> runtime
>
> noarch 2.1.11-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 1.0 M
> bluez-
> libs
>
> x86_64 5.51-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 171 k
> daxctl-
> libs
>
> x86_64 67-
> 1.fc31
>
> @updates 94 k
> device-mapper-
> multipath
> x86_64 0.8.0-
> 3.fc31
>
> @fedora 281 k
> device-mapper-multipath-
> libs
> x86_64 0.8.0-
> 3.fc31
>
> @fedora 881 k
> dmraid
>
> x86_64 1.0.0.rc16-
> 43.fc31
> @fedora 359 k
> dmraid-
> events
>
> x86_64 1.0.0.rc16-
> 43.fc31
> @fedora 17 k
> initial-
> setup
>
> x86_64 0.3.76-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 230 k
> keybinder3
>
> x86_64 0.3.2-
> 7.fc31
>
> @fedora 32 k
> kf5-modemmanager-
> qt
> x86_64 5.61.0-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 901 k
> ldns
>
> x86_64 1.7.0-
> 26.fc31
>
> @fedora 422 k
> libblockdev-
> btrfs
> x86_64 2.23-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 28 k
> libblockdev-
> dm
> x86_64 2.23-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 24 k
> libblockdev-
> kbd
> x86_64 2.23-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 40 k
> libblockdev-
> lvm
> x86_64 2.23-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 52 k
> libblockdev-
> mpath
> x86_64 2.23-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 24 k
> libblockdev-
> nvdimm
> x86_64 2.23-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 24 k
> libgnomekbd
>
> x86_64 3.26.1-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 632 k
> libndp
>
> x86_64 1.7-
> 4.fc31
>
> @fedora 107 k
> libnl3-
> cli
>
> x86_64 3.5.0-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 1.0 M
> libnma
>
> x86_64 1.8.22-
> 1.fc31.1
>
> @fedora 524 k
> libpskc
>
> x86_64 2.6.2-
> 3.fc31
>
> @fedora 92 k
> libreport-
> anaconda
>
> x86_64 2.10.1-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 18 k
> libreswan
>
> x86_64 3.29-
> 1.fc31.1
>
> @fedora 4.5 M
> libteam
>
> x86_64 1.29-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 160 k
> libtimezonemap
>
> x86_64 0.4.5.1-
> 6.fc31
>
> @fedora 6.7 M
> libxklavier
>
> x86_64 5.4-
> 14.fc31
>
> @fedora 165 k
> mobile-broadband-provider-
> info
> noarch 20190618-
> 2.fc31
> @fedora 488 k
> ndctl
>
> x86_64 67-
> 1.fc31
>
> @updates 363 k
> ndctl-
> libs
>
> x86_64 67-
> 1.fc31
>
> @updates 350 k
> nm-connection-
> editor
> x86_64 1.8.22-
> 1.fc31.1
>
> @fedora 5.6 M
> openconnect
>
> x86_64 8.05-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 2.8 M
> openvpn
>
> x86_64 2.4.7-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 1.3 M
> pkcs11-
> helper
>
> x86_64 1.22-
> 8.fc31
>
> @fedora 156 k
> plasma-
> nm
>
> x86_64 5.16.5-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 4.9 M
> pptp
>
> x86_64 1.10.0-
> 7.fc31
>
> @fedora 161 k
> python3-
> blivet
>
> noarch 1:3.1.5-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 3.2 M
> python3-
> blockdev
>
> x86_64 2.23-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 80 k
> python3-
> bytesize
>
> x86_64 2.1-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 40 k
> python3-
> kickstart
>
> noarch 3.21-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 2.3 M
> python3-
> langtable
>
> noarch 0.0.47-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 1.2 M
> python3-
> meh
>
> noarch 0.48-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 284 k
> python3-meh-
> gui
> noarch 0.48-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 24 k
> python3-
> ntplib
>
> noarch 0.3.3-
> 15.fc31
>
> @fedora 28 k
> python3-
> pid
>
> noarch 2.2.3-
> 3.fc31
>
> @fedora 35 k
> python3-
> productmd
>
> noarch 1.21-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 248 k
> python3-
> pwquality
>
> x86_64 1.4.1-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 25 k
> python3-
> pyparted
>
> x86_64 1:3.11.2-
> 2.fc31
> @fedora 364 k
> python3-
> pyudev
>
> noarch 0.21.0-
> 11.fc31
>
> @fedora 315 k
> python3-requests-
> file
> noarch 1.4.3-
> 11.fc31
>
> @fedora 9.4 k
> python3-requests-
> ftp
> noarch 0.3.1-
> 15.fc31
>
> @fedora 37 k
> python3-
> simpleline
>
> noarch 1.6-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 440 k
> sgpio
>
> x86_64 1.2.0.10-
> 24.fc31
> @fedora 24 k
> stoken-
> libs
>
> x86_64 0.91-
> 8.fc31
>
> @fedora 94 k
> teamd
>
> x86_64 1.29-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 282 k
> tigervnc-
> license
>
> noarch 1.9.0-
> 7.fc31
>
> @fedora 18 k
> tigervnc-server-
> minimal
> x86_64 1.9.0-
> 7.fc31
>
> @fedora 3.0 M
> tpm2-
> tss
>
> x86_64 2.3.1-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 1.2 M
> userspace-
> rcu
>
> x86_64 0.11.1-
> 2.fc31
>
> @fedora 417 k
> vpnc
>
> x86_64 0.5.3-
> 36.svn550.fc31
>
> @fedora 212 k
> vpnc-
> script
>
> noarch
> 20171004-
> 6.git6f87b0f.fc31
> @fedora 26 k
> wpa_supplicant
>
> x86_64 1:2.9-
> 2.fc31
>
> @updates 5.2 M
> xl2tpd
>
> x86_64 1.3.14-
> 1.fc31
>
> @fedora 211 k
>
> Transaction Summary
> =====================================================================
> =====================================================================
> =====================================================================
> =====================================================================
> ======
> Remove 90 Packages
>
> Freed space: 86 M
> Operation aborted.
>
> On Friday, November 8, 2019 8:14:54 PM CST Ryan Gonzalez wrote:
> > Having two networking systems running at once can cause all sorts
> > of
> > problems, not sure if this is the issue here or why NM is still
> > starting
> > but you can try using 'systemctl mask' on it to completely prevent
> > it from
> > running.
> >
> > On Fri, Nov 8, 2019, 7:37 PM Anthony Joseph Messina <
> > amessina at messinet.com>
> > wrote: I apologize if this isn't the right place to post this
> > request for
> > assistance. I've attempted the Fedora User's list with no luck and
> > would
> > prefer to ask before filing a bug.
> >
> > After a successful "dnf systemd upgrade" F30->F31, I'm finding that
> > a few of
> > my machines which use systemd-networkd instead of NetworkManager
> > are no
> > longer autoconfiguring IPv6 addresses. I also noticed that even
> > though
> > NetworkManager is disabled, it is initiated in early boot, which
> > I'm not
> > sure is related.
> >
> > It appears as though the system isn't assigning the link-local
> > address and
> > therefore can't communicate via IPv6. If anyone has any pointers
> > on where
> > to begin, I'd appreciate it. Thanks. -A
> >
> > Both systems below use the following
> > /etc/systemd/network/10-wired-dhcp.network:
> >
> > [Match]
> > Name=en*
> >
> > [Network]
> > DHCP=yes
> > IPv6PrivacyExtensions=yes
> >
> >
> > Both systems are running:
> > kernel-5.3.8-300.fc31.x86_64
> > systemd-243-4.gitef67743.fc31.x86_64
> > NetworkManager-1.20.4-1.fc31.x86_64
> >
> >
> > A system that IS working with systemd-networkd displays the
> > following debug
> > output:
> >
> > eno1: New device has no master, continuing without
> > eno1: Flags change: +UP +LOWER_UP +RUNNING +MULTICAST +BROADCAST
> > eno1: Link 2 added
> > eno1: udev initialized link
> > eno1: State changed: pending -> initialized
> > eno1: Saved original MTU: 1500
> > eno1: Remembering foreign address: fe80::f64d:30ff:fe6e:2cf5/64
> > (valid
> > forever) eno1: Gained IPv6LL
> > eno1: Remembering route: dst: ff00::/8, src: n/a, gw: n/a, prefsrc:
> > n/a,
> > scope: global, table: local, proto: boot, type: unicast eno1:
> > Remembering
> > route: dst: fe80::f64d:30ff:fe6e:2cf5/128, src: n/a, gw: n/a,
> > prefsrc: n/a,
> > scope: global, table: local, proto: kernel, type: local eno1:
> > Remembering
> > route: dst: fe80::/64, src: n/a, gw: n/a, prefsrc: n/a, scope:
> > global,
> > table: main, proto: kernel, type: unicast eno1: Remembering updated
> > address: fe80::f64d:30ff:fe6e:2cf5/64 (valid forever) eno1:
> > Updating
> > remembered route: dst: fe80::f64d:30ff:fe6e:2cf5/128, src: n/a, gw:
> > n/a,
> > prefsrc: n/a, scope: global, table: local, proto: kernel, type:
> > local eno1:
> > Link state is up-to-date
> > eno1: found matching network '/etc/systemd/network/10-wired-
> > dhcp.network'
> > Setting '/proc/sys/net/ipv6/conf/eno1/disable_ipv6' to '0'
> > eno1: IPv6 successfully enabled
> > Setting '/proc/sys/net/ipv6/conf/eno1/proxy_ndp' to '0'
> > Setting '/proc/sys/net/ipv6/conf/eno1/use_tempaddr' to '2'
> > Setting '/proc/sys/net/ipv6/conf/eno1/accept_ra' to '0'
> > eno1: Started LLDP.
> > eno1: Setting address genmode for link
> > eno1: Acquiring DHCPv4 lease
> > eno1: Discovering IPv6 routers
> > eno1: State changed: initialized -> configuring
> > eno1: Acquiring DHCPv6 lease on NDisc request
> >
> >
> > Another system that IS NOT working displays the following debug
> > output (note
> > the missing Remembering foreign address and Gained IPv6LL lines):
> >
> > eno1: New device has no master, continuing without
> > eno1: Flags change: +UP +LOWER_UP +RUNNING +MULTICAST +BROADCAST
> > eno1: Link 2 added
> > eno1: udev initialized link
> > eno1: State changed: pending -> initialized
> > eno1: Saved original MTU: 1500
> > eno1: Remembering route: dst: ff00::/8, src: n/a, gw: n/a, prefsrc:
> > n/a,
> > scope: global, table: local, proto: boot, type: unicast eno1: Link
> > state is
> > up-to-date
> > eno1: found matching network '/etc/systemd/network/10-wired-
> > dhcp.network'
> > eno1: IPv6 successfully enabled
> > eno1: Started LLDP.
> > eno1: Setting address genmode for link
> > eno1: Acquiring DHCPv4 lease
> > eno1: State changed: initialized -> configuring
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> systemd-devel mailing list
> systemd-devel at lists.freedesktop.org
> https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/systemd-devel
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: signature.asc
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 833 bytes
Desc: This is a digitally signed message part
URL: <https://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/systemd-devel/attachments/20191109/67836c4a/attachment-0001.sig>