[systemd-devel] Is systemd-cryptsetup binary internal?

mpan systemdml-bfok4d2c at mpan.pl
Mon Sep 18 13:22:24 UTC 2023


Hello,

   I got redirected to here from #systemd on Libera. While responding to 
a query from another person (not on #systemd), I came across an 
ambiguity. Any answer I give, its validity would be uncertain. I wish to 
receive an authoritative clarification.

   There is systemd-cryptsetup binary in “/usr/lib/systemd/”. Its 
location suggests it’s internal to systemd and not intended for user 
invocation. However, it is also listed in manual as if it was something 
the user might be concerned with. The manual even has a specific, 
separate, explicit reference to systemd-cryptsetup page — though it’s 
shared with the corresponding service and the binary itself isn’t described.

   Thanks in advance for indicating, if systemd-cryptsetup (the binary) 
is a tool users may rely on.

Cheers!

PS  Please note that I don’t want to argue with anybody, what is their 
opinion on this matter. I reach out to systemd-devel to obtain an 
authoritative answer. Stable interfaces page is not actually answering 
the above question, “all binaries have entries in manual” is not true, 
placement in “/usr/lib” is already mentioned by me, and I am aware that 
systemd-cryptsetup at .service and systemd-cryptsetup the binary are related.


More information about the systemd-devel mailing list