[Tango-artists] Lumix & cassette

[Jonathan Zuniga]

André Wyrwa wrote:
> Hei,
>
> On Tue, 2007-05-22 at 23:57 -0700, Jonathan Zuniga wrote:
>   
>> Hi, I created two icons in tango style, the Panasonic Lumix DMC-FX01 and 
>> one analog audio tape cassette.****
>>     
>
> Beautiful.
>
> I missed inner highlighted outlines in both icons...for the tape it's at
> the case extension bit, for the camera it's at the front top edge.
>
> I added them in the versions attached, please review. (Beware, i'm using
> the same filenames.)
>
>   
Thank you André and to all for your comments, much appreciated.

I really like how it looks in the tape, but in the camera i think it's 
not necessary (more overloded, imho).
> Minor (really!) comments for the camera...
> - The "reflections" on the lens casing look a bit funny to me...i guess
> what i mean is that the upper right quarter of the outer circle is a bit
> bright compared to the lower left. I can think of why you are doing this
> and it seems like a great idea, however, the outlines get very dominant
> in that section and it looks almost like the light is coming from the
> upper right.
> - The reflections, particularly on the left edge, seem somewhat
> strong...or somewhat incosistent with the non-reflecting top.
> - I love your lens flare implementation.
>
>   
I will try to improve that part this weekend.
> Just to emphasize that again...the icon looks great as is, it's just
> minor oddities i recognized.
>
> Also...a question...
> I noticed you are giving the icons a 1px empty border. I'm usually not
> doing that in mine, but thought about it because i realized, gnome
> doesn't necessarily add any border around icons (i.e. in the panel). Do
> we have a general policy on that?
>
> André.
>   
thanks, about the border i don't know but it would be great if some of 
the experts clear that detail. :)

- Jonathan
>   
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>