[Wayland-bugs] [Bug 52077] New: implement modern clipboard

[bugzilla-daemon at freedesktop.org]

https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=52077

             Bug #: 52077
           Summary: implement modern clipboard
    Classification: Unclassified
           Product: Wayland
           Version: unspecified
          Platform: x86-64 (AMD64)
        OS/Version: Linux (All)
            Status: NEW
          Severity: enhancement
          Priority: medium
         Component: wayland
        AssignedTo: wayland-bugs at lists.freedesktop.org
        ReportedBy: pyrates at mindless.com


Please implement a modern clipboard while wayland is still being developed. 
It's such a shame that linux itself has never had a proper one.  Instead work
arounds such as clipboard managers, that only handle text, are implemented. 
Here's how it works with xorg:

1.  You copy some text storing the location in memory where that text is
2.  You then tell another program to paste that text
3.  The program goes back to the xorg clipboard and asks for the text to be
pasted
4.  The xorg clipboard asks the program that the text is supposed to come from
for the text
5.  That program then says here is the text
6.  The text is then pasted into the new program

Now this process breaks if you close the original program before doing the
pasting.  Windows and Mac users find this very frustrating!  Now the supposed
fix is for each program to "check" if there is any data that the clipboard is
pointing to.  Some have done it, but the vast majority have not because those
developers are use to the way windows and mac do it, where it handles it for
them and they don't have to worry about it.

Also that selection based clipboard thing has got to go.  It's only useful in
the terminal because the terminal already was using the ctrl+c, ctrl+v, ctrl+x
shortcut commands.  So instead of making it system wide, make it on a per
application basis when those applications need it.  For example on windows,
selection based copying works on mirc and putty, because they implemented it
for only them to use it.  So if another program wants selection based copying,
then that program can implement it.  Not many programs will I bet.

Now here is how we could redo it:

1.  When copying text, copy both the plain text version and the stylized
version.  Any text pasting program can then specify if they want the stylized
version, and if they don't, then they get the plain version.  But they still
need to specify they want text as the type.
2.  Copying audio will identify that it is audio and programs that work with
that, will expect that.  This way 2 audio programs can interact with each
other.
3.  Copying video will identify that it is video and programs that work with
that, will expect that.  This way 2 video programs can interact with each
other.
4.  Copying files/directories will store the location of where the
file/directory is and the name of it.  This will identify itself as a
file/directory when doing pasting of it.  There will be 2 types though, one for
a file, and one for a directory.  This way if the file manager needs to have a
special way to handle a file and another way to handle a directory, it can do
that.  Same thing if it's a symbolic link, both for soft and hard kinds being
each of their own.
5.  For any other kinds of data, it will have a unique identifier that wayland
has to support.  So if we need to add more types of data that the clipboard
will support, we can do that.
6.  Finally we will be copying the data to the clipboard, not storing a pointer
to it.  This solves the problem of what happens if you copy the data and then
close the program before pasting it that frustrates so many windows and mac
users who try out linux.
7.  One more thing, when a program quits and has data in the clipboard over a
certain size, the program or wayland, will intercept when that program is told
to quit, asking the user if they want to clear the clipboard or not since it
would free up some memory.

Now this would be all nice if it was implemented.  And since wayland is still
under development, I believe a proper implemented clipboard is the way to go.

And here's a rant on it:

http://elliotth.blogspot.com/2008/08/desktop-linux-suckage-clipboard.html

-- 
Configure bugmail: https://bugs.freedesktop.org/userprefs.cgi?tab=email
------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are the assignee for the bug.