Add z-order control into kiosk-shell?

[Hoosier, Matt]

To make this a little more concrete, I put together MR https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/wayland/weston/-/merge_requests/702.

________________________________
From: Hoosier, Matt
Sent: Friday, October 1, 2021 2:32:04 PM
To: wayland-devel at lists.freedesktop.org
Subject: Add z-order control into kiosk-shell?

I've been very happy to see kiosk-shell get introduced in the past year or so. It seems to tick nearly every box that I frequently find myself wanting when trying to do embedded deployment of pre-existing Wayland apps which expect to use the customary desktop-centric shells:


  *   declarative control over which output gets which surface
  *   force the apps full-screen by default
  *   no new protocols needed

So this is really nice. Much lower barrier to entry than IVI Shell, and certainly a better re-use story for off-the-rack applications.

But there's a niche that doesn't have any obvious answer yet: controlling the stacking order of different toplevel apps. It's fairly common to construct an embedded system using distributed rendering from separate programs. This means you need a way to control which things go above or below each other to achieve the overall effect.

Would there be any interest in a contribution to enhance kiosk-shell to support configurable stacking orders? This might take the form of either relative specifications ("desktop surface XYZ always goes above desktop surface UWV") or absolute z-order specifications ("desktop surface XYZ's surfaces go into weston_layer #17").

I haven't thought deeply yet about how the syntax for setting the stacking-order configuration in weston.ini would look. Maybe some kind of subscript annotation following the surface ID?

    [output]
    name=LVDS1
    # app1 goes in weston_layer 0. app2 goes in weston_layer 1
    app-ids=org.domain.app1[0],com.domain.app2[1]

Or maybe allow more than one "app-ids" line, keyed by a subscript?

    [output]
    name=LVDS1
    app-ids[layer0]=org.domain.app1,...
    app-ids[layer1]=org.domain.app3,...

-Matt
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/wayland-devel/attachments/20211006/2664caed/attachment.htm>