[Clipart] Misunderstanding about CC0/PD

[Nicu Buculei]

S.Kemter wrote:
> Hi,
>
> again stop interpreting laws, I told you before there is a difference
> between
>
> impression and attribution,
>
> I can say "Nicu Buculei is in my opinion to stupid to read licenses and
> understand laws" or I can say "Nicu Buculei is to stupid to read licenses
> and understand laws". The first one is very clear marked as opinion and
> leaves the decision if the message is true or not to the receiver of the
> message, the other one is a statement and there cant be made an decission,
> because its already made.

Don't be so fast throwing insults at me, better have a look at the other
replies you received and see they say the same thing as me. Perhaps we
aren't all stupid, but you misunderstood the license.

> Impression is saying "I worked very hard to collect the clipart" that
> leaves the decission if you made them open. Some might think that collect
> means you created them some read more carefully. But saying "I worked hard
> to create them" is attribution and that right is after CC0 still be owned
> by the waiver/creator.
>
> The whole discussion you started, shows at least to me you are amongst the
> people that would read in "collect" - "create"

Nope, I fully understand the difference from "collect" and "create", but I
also understand we accepted to distribute our works under a license that
make this difference irrelevant. We are talking about CC0/PD, not CC-BY.

> You way out of line, but you dont get it. You question me after the
> acceptance of that term, where did I ever say I dont accept it? I just
> told
> you that you have to read that term more carefully.  That term doesnt deny
> me as creator my moral rights or where is it written, that it is allowed
> to
> SAY that you have created it?

Accepting the terms of the site you allowed people to say that. Maybe is
our fault we didn't make it clear enough for the contributors, but those
are the terms.

> For the law is a difference between a lie and not telling the truth.

Nobody is lying.

-- 
nicu :: http://nicubunu.ro :: http://nicubunu.blogspot.com