[pulseaudio-discuss] 0.9.15 bluetooth profiles question

[Jon Escombe]

On 30/04/09 08:55, Johan Hedberg wrote:
> Hi Jon,
>
> On Thu, Apr 30, 2009, Jon Escombe wrote:
>    
>> Have just found these descriptions on the bluez wiki -
>>    org.bluez.AudioSink.Connect - connects via A2DP (stereo audio)
>>    org.bluez.Headset.Connect - connects via HSP/HFP (mono headset with mic)
>>    org.bluez.Audio.Connect - connects to both (select which to use via
>> the pulse card profile)
>>
>> If I connect from the Audio node, I can disconnect the Headset node.
>> If I connect from the Audio node, I can not disconnect the AudioSink
>> node "org.bluez.Error.NotConnected: Device not Connected"
>> I can not directly connect from the AudioSink node
>> "org.bluez.Error.Failed: Stream setup failed"
>>
>> So it looks like pulse is accurately reflecting the underlying behavior,
>> perhaps I should take this to the bluetooth list?
>>      
>
> You could do that, but I'll (as one of the BlueZ developers) answer here
> anyway. To investigate the issue it'd be good to gather some bluetooth
> related logs. The following would be of interest:
>   - bluetoothd logs with the -d switch
>   - dbus-monitor --system sender=org.bluez
>   - hcidump. You may need to filter this to avoid the SCO traffic
>     (something like "hcidump -XV hci rfcomm avdtp"
>
> Also, before all this you may want to enable HFP in
> /etc/bluetooth/audio.conf since in my experience HSP (which seems to be
> the default in most distros) receives less testing amongst headset
> manufacturers and can therefore exhibit interesting issues.
>
> Johan
>    

Thanks johan,

Fedora doesn't seem to ship an audio.conf, so a grabbed one from the 
bluez tarball and enabled HFP. As soon as I did this the connection 
worked perfectly. :)

However, and this seems a bit weird, I thought I'd then revert to HSP 
and grab some failure logs. But ever since this first successful 
connection, I'm unable to reproduce the failure, no matter whether HFP 
is enabled or not! Is there any persistent config for that connection 
that I should be clearing out?

Regards,
Jon