Plan: BO move throttling for visible VRAM evictions
maraeo at gmail.com
Fri Mar 24 16:33:59 UTC 2017
I'm sharing this idea here, because it's something that has been
decreasing our performance a lot recently, for example:
I think the problem there is that Mesa git started uploading
descriptors and uniforms to VRAM, which helps when TC L2 has a low
hit/miss ratio, but the performance can randomly drop by an order of
magnitude. I've heard rumours that kernel 4.11 has an improved
allocator that should perform better, but the situation is still far
AMD CPUs and APUs will hopefully suffer less, because we can resize
the visible VRAM with the help of our CPU hw specs, but Intel CPUs
will remain limited to 256 MB. The following plan describes how to do
throttling for visible VRAM evictions.
Initially, the driver doesn't care about where buffers are in VRAM,
because VRAM buffers are only moved to visible VRAM on CPU page faults
(when the CPU touches the buffer memory but the memory is in the
invisible part of VRAM). When it happens,
amdgpu_bo_fault_reserve_notify is called, which moves the buffer to
visible VRAM, and the app continues. amdgpu_bo_fault_reserve_notify
also marks the buffer as contiguous, which makes memory fragmentation
I verified this with DiRT Rally where amdgpu_bo_fault_reserve_notify
was much higher in a CPU profiler than anything else in the kernel.
2) Monitoring via Gallium HUD
We need to expose 2 kernel counters via the INFO ioctl and display
those via Gallium HUD:
- The number of VRAM CPU page faults. (the number of calls to
- The number of bytes moved by ttm_bo_validate inside
This will help us observe what exactly is happening and fine-tune the
throttling when it's done.
a) When amdgpu_bo_fault_reserve_notify is called, record the fact.
(amdgpu_bo::had_cpu_page_fault = true)
b) Monitor the MB/s rate at which buffers are moved by
amdgpu_bo_fault_reserve_notify. If we get above a specific threshold,
don't move the buffer to visible VRAM. Move it to GTT instead. Note
that moving to GTT can be cheaper, because moving to visible VRAM is
likely to evict a lot of buffers there and unmap them from the CPU,
but moving to GTT shouldn't evict or unmap anything.
c) When we get into the CS ioctl and a buffer has had_cpu_page_fault,
it can be moved to VRAM if:
- the GTT->VRAM move rate is low enough to allow it (this is the
existing throttling mechanism)
- the visible VRAM move rate is low enough that we will be OK with
another CPU page fault if it happens.
d) The solution can be fine-tuned with the help of Gallium HUD to get
the best performance under various scenarios. The current throttling
mechanism can serve as an inspiration.
That's it. Feel free to comment. I think this is our biggest
performance bottleneck at the moment.
More information about the amd-gfx