[CREATE] assets library

Cyrille Berger cberger at cberger.net
Fri Sep 28 11:31:09 PDT 2007


> > I don't know about ICC enought to comment. But HTML do not allow
> > extension on the spec, it's just that some main stream web browsers have
> > extension to the spec, meaning some websites use them, meaning other web
> > browsers have to cope finding information for the extension, while 99% of
> > what is in the extension could have been done with a full implementation
> > of the spec. TIFF and OpenEXR, I can't count people asking us to support
> > one of this undocumented extension.
>
> In text formats, if no other meachanism is provided, often new things
> start to appear in comments ;-)
yeah :) or tags are added anyway. But I am offering a mechanism, comes here to 
ask for the change !

> For instance the ICC profile in Tiff (v6.0 1992) is defined in the ICC
> spec (1995?) not vice versa. Tiff was easy enough extensible to do such
> things, Exif, geo referencing ... Ok, Adobe registers new TIFF tags on
> request. But this makes no new standard.
Sure and they don't require documentation, so half of those tags are only used 
by a few applications.

> Blender with its layer and compositing stack, exhibited in the OpenEXR
> images is nowhere described in the OpenEXR spec. Even though it is
> possible with this format.
Yes and now people are asking for Krita to support multilayer OpenEXR and I 
have a hard time finding information. While with a central place with all the 
information it's much easier ;) And from what I have heard, the multi layer 
things is supposed to move into the spec.

I could also add as an example, Exif, which includes a field where 
manufacturer are allowed to insert whatever data they want, and some of them 
are inserting metadata in that field which could be described in the spec.

I do think the create group is a reasonnable group so that if someone wants 
something, I think it will be easily added.

-- 
Cyrille Berger


More information about the CREATE mailing list