[Libreoffice-qa] Extensive docx conversion tests...

[Joel Madero]

Incredible work Jay - hope to see you in the chat and hopefully on the 
call going forward. Really really helpful.


Warm Regards,
Joel



On 04/21/2014 08:51 PM, Jay Philips wrote:
> Hi Robinson,
>
> Thanks for cc'ing me as i wasnt part of the list but have sent in a 
> request to be part of it.
>
>> Jay -- Thanks for the legwork here! As of right now all of your
> UNCONFIRMED bug reports have had their status updated to NEW,
> ASSIGNED, or FIXED. Got any more compat bugs to report? :-)
>
> Your welcome and thank you for looking into the bugs i have already 
> submitted. If you want a compat bug which i just confirmed while 
> writing this message but still havent reported, here is one. in the 
> last 2 test documents i have been working on, if you open the .docx in 
> calligra words and then save it as a odf, and then open that odt in 
> libO, the tables will be crushed flat, allowing 1 character per line. 
> I initially thought this was isolated, but it happen in both documents 
> i opened which had tables in it though calligra words was able to 
> reopen it fine. i then tested opening the file in word 2010 and the 
> tables weren't perfect but still okay, but i'm assuming it has to be 
> related to word 2010's odf compatibility.
>
> I am currently finishing off the 3rd test document i've been working 
> on, but i have only submitted the major bugs that i've found in these 
> tests. I report most of the bugs on my twitter account < 
> https://twitter.com/jphilipz/ > as i'm also testing kingsoft writer 
> and calligra works, but after i complete the tests, i take all the 
> tweets and put them into a text file and then .zip it along with all 
> the test documents created during the test, and i place them at a 
> public url for interested parties to have access to. As this is my 
> current work flow, its difficult to make individual bug reports for 
> each individual problem that occurs during the testing, but i will try 
> to submit more. If i were permitted, i would like to send into the 
> list a more customized test result .zip file just of libreoffice bugs, 
> which would contain the related tweets (along with its related bug 
> reports i've sent in), created test documents, and images of the 
> errors. With this, i'm assuming it would be easy for the devs to 
> create the necessary bugs reports with.
>
> So far in this 3rd test i've been using < http://bit.ly/QBBwfV >, and 
> here are the tweets related to libreoffice and i've added '[reported]' 
> to the end of the ones i've reported in bugzilla.
>
> test3: @libreoffice opened docx close to perfection except for a 
> slight spacing issues and an incorrect font size - http://img.ly/yEH3
> test3: @libreoffice 4.0's opened the .doc close to perfection except 
> for a table width not being constant - img.ly/yEH7
> test3: @libreoffice 4.1+'s had the same table issue in the .doc, as 
> well as a problem with the heading - http://img.ly/yEHe
> test3: @libreoffice 4.1+'s opening of the .doc also had a problem of 
> showing a purple line at the top of each page - http://img.ly/yEIY
>
> test3: unable to export .docx into another .docx in @libreoffice 4.2 
> as the UI crashes with an error dialog - http://img.ly/yFvh [reported]
> test3: reopening saved rtf in @libreoffice 3.6 to 4.2 returns a file 
> format error dialog box - http://img.ly/yFvC [reported]
> test3: reopening saved odf 1.1 in @libreoffice causes loss of numbered 
> and bullet list indentation, as well as paragraph spacing issues
> test3: reopening saved odf 1.2 and .doc in @libreoffice was exactly 
> like the original, plus it didnt have the incorrect font size issue
> test3: reopened docx in @libreoffice 4.1 and it has missing background 
> color behind document heading - http://img.ly/yFye
>
> test3: opened @Kingsoft_Office doc in @libreoffice and each page had a 
> pink line in its header and font styles were off
> test3: opened @Kingsoft_Office docx in @libreoffice and document title 
> was missing, and incorrect number list style - http://img.ly/yFxt
> test3: opened @Kingsoft_Office rtf in @libreoffice and the results 
> were bad mainly due to incorrect font sizes for bullet list items
>
> test3: opened @calligrasuite odf in @libreoffice and it has 24 pages 
> as tables are crushed flat and first page document heading is missing 
> [first part mentioned above]
>
> I look forward working with you and the QA team.
>
> Jay Philips
>
> On 04/21/2014 03:07 AM, Robinson Tryon wrote:
>> Aaaaaaand I should probably cc Jay here, as I'm not sure he's on the 
>> list :-)
>>
>> --R
>>
>> On Sun, Apr 20, 2014 at 4:05 PM, Robinson Tryon
>> <bishop.robinson at gmail.com> wrote:
>>> [was: [documentliberation-discuss] two docx conversion test results on
>>> LibreOffice]
>>>
>>> Dear QA Team,
>>>
>>> Please say hi to Jay Philips who is currently doing extensive...well,
>>> let's just read what he wrote:
>>>
>>> On Sat, Apr 19, 2014 at 6:22 AM, Jay Philips <philipz85 at hotmail.com> 
>>> wrote:
>>>> I am doing extensive docx and doc conversion tests on libreoffice 
>>>> from files
>>>> pulled from microsoft's website...
>>>>
>>>> [...testing with LibreOffice, MSO compatibility pack, etc...]
>>>>
>>>> I also send in bug reports for a number of the bugs i find.
>>>> <
>>>> https://bugs.freedesktop.org/buglist.cgi?emailreporter1=1&list_id=415544&emailtype1=substring&query_format=advanced&email1=philipz85%40hotmail.com&product=LibreOffice 
>>>>
>>> Jay -- Thanks for the legwork here! As of right now all of your
>>> UNCONFIRMED bug reports have had their status updated to NEW,
>>> ASSIGNED, or FIXED. Got any more compat bugs to report? :-)
>>>
>>> Cheers,
>>> --R
>>>
>>> -- 
>>> Robinson Tryon
>>> LibreOffice Community Outreach Herald
>>> Senior QA Troublemaker
>>> The Document Foundation
>>> qubit at libreoffice.org
>
> _______________________________________________
> List Name: Libreoffice-qa mailing list
> Mail address: Libreoffice-qa at lists.freedesktop.org
> Change settings: 
> http://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/libreoffice-qa
> Problems? 
> http://www.libreoffice.org/get-help/mailing-lists/how-to-unsubscribe/
> Posting guidelines + more: http://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Netiquette
> List archive: http://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/libreoffice-qa/