[Piglit] Over three thousand crashes on opengl driver of ADM&NV caused by commit b28cdc887aefb1e766719e1f74d457f77bdf9a18

Brian Paul brianp at vmware.com
Thu Apr 3 06:59:42 PDT 2014

On 04/03/2014 03:42 AM, Fu, Ping wrote:
> Hi Justen,
> I tested the latest piglit and found lots of crashes(Over three
> thousand) on both AMD and NVIDIA. This might be caused by your commit
> b28cdc887aefb1e766719e1f74d457f77bdf9a18 on shader_runner.c.
> According to page 363 and 360 of glspec44.compatibility for
> glVertexPointer: “An INVALID_OPERATION error is generated if a non-zero
> vertex array object is bound, no buffer is bound to ARRAY_BUFFER, and
> pointer is not NULL.”  So if app who wants to use VAO, should obey the
> following gl call sequence:
> glGenVertexArrays
> glBindVertexArray
> glGenBuffers
> glBindBuffer
> glBufferData
> glVertexAttribPointer
> But now the red part missed under current code path when
> use_fixed_function_attributes and INVALID_OPERATION was returned by
> subsequent glVertexAttribPointer. Then both AMD and NVIDIA crashed on
> subsequent glDrawArrays. Besides, mesa driver’s gl_version=30 so it
> followed another code path which didn’t use VAO, and had no crash.

Thanks for investigating that!  I saw a ton of failures on NVIDIA too in 
a recent test run that I did.  I didn't have time to did into it though.


More information about the Piglit mailing list