[systemd-devel] [PATCH v7] run: introduce timer support option

"J├│hann B. Gu├░mundsson" johannbg at gmail.com
Wed Dec 10 06:36:31 PST 2014


On 12/10/2014 12:05 PM, Lennart Poettering wrote:
> No. At least on Fedora we only have a limited number of system cron
> jobs,

Right less then 45 ( out of 100 in total ) that might have been 
applicable for migration

> and I'd rather see those converted natively, rather than
> maintaining a compatibility generator for a longer time

Right arguably upstream should never carry generators of anykind ( and 
at one point we will need to drop the legacy sysv initscript 
compatibility otherwise those legacy initscripts will never get migrated 
and their daemon be fixed either if applicable ) and beside the 
limitation that timer units suffer from, cron generators can create 
quite the surprise for administrators, especially on batch servers.

That said out of necessity ( It's easier to write a generator rather 
then go through the leg work and bureaucracy of dealing with 
distribution processes )  there has already been written by Dwayne Bent, 
Konstantin Stepanov, Daniel Schaal and Alexandre Detiste an 
"systemd-crontab" which includes crontab generator which can be found 
here [1]

But I urge distribution integrators to go the extra mile and rather 
migrate existing cron jobs for components that already depend on systemd 
and or are part of the core/base OS and might thus benefit from that 
migration.

I would have migrating all the relevant cron jobs in Fedora but I had 
enough due to certain corporate attitude towards the project, certain 
part of their employees and their behaviour and as a result of that in 
the end things turned out differently than I had planned or anticipated.

That work would have most likely covered everything that should have 
been migrated in Mageia,OpenSuse and Arch ( Debian is of a different 
Scale ) but you know shit happens and things go unfixed as an result of 
that.

JBG

1. https://github.com/kstep/systemd-crontab-generator
2. https://github.com/systemd-cron/systemd-cron


More information about the systemd-devel mailing list